Malaysia tidak perlukan pelarian dan hipokrasi UNHCR

[Nota: Posting blogger Just Read menarik perhatian saya. Ini menambah koleksi pengetahuan kita mengenai hipokrasi Barat dan UNHCR dalam menangani isu pelarian. UNHCR bukan peduli sangat tentang pelarian, sebaliknya hanya suka menunding jari dan mencari kesalahan pihak lain, dan dalam kes ini negara kita Malaysia. Ada beberapa komen yang menarik yang saya petik dari blog Just Read, antaranya :-

indigo said...

by the way, the situation in myanmar is getting better.
so, their what so called refugees should be stopped from finding refuge in malaysia.
we already have too many of them, many are taking advantage of the status.
unhcr must also monitor situation the myanmar as to verify their status.

copacabana said...

stop taking them. send them home or to third countries who only know how to talk nonsense about our treatment here. use the millions of ringgit allocated for the refugees to improve rural roads and others. no point being the nice guy if our efforts go down the drain.

if malaysia is a dangerous country, tell unhcr that we will no anymore allow refugees to step foot on our land... or we will shoot them!

September 24, 2011 12:35 PM

cuka getah said...

memang ada yang jadi penyamun tapi bukan sebab tak cukup makan tapi memang asalnya penyamun di negara sendiri. sebab tu lari dan ambil kesempatan jadi pelarian serta bernaung di bawah UNHCR.

siapa kata kita tak bagi mereka makan?

buatlah siasatan dengan pejabat UNHCR di kuala lumpur berapa banyak malaysia belanja untuk mereka.

UNHCR pun kita bayar.

sial betul diorang ni!

September 24, 2011 12:40 PM

Chau said...

Why the number of the refugees is increasing? There used to be only Chin ( in the pics) from Myanmar under UNHCR protection in our country in the early stage of 2000 who are very humble and hardworking people apart from their drinking behavior .I have employed so many of them and helped them as they make me rich. Huu... I only regard these people as refugees who should be protected by the govt and UNHCR because they are the most discriminated ones in Myanmar for their religion ( Christian).

September 24, 2011 3:01 PM

Baca artikel Just Read di bawah:

Malaysia is too dangerous!

I will go on writing about the same issue - UNHCR refugees in Malaysia. We have been battered all around for being the nice guys, all because of bad reporting and badmouthing by some 'double agents', including few Malaysians who play chummy to the international organisations and foreign governments.

Please bear in mind that we have yet to ratify the UN Refugee Convention but we play host to so many refugees.

This refugee camp is so close to the KLIA

We even signed a swap deal with Australia with the intention to help those refugees but here they go again, labeling Malaysia as the most dangerous country (here) for refugees. Why in the first place we signed up with them?

If we are not a signatory to the Convention, can can always chase them from our territory or flush them out. But we have been too kind enough. I think we should review out stand on this. Rather than being diplomatically-abused over the matter, we should from now on refrain from opening our doors to them.

As a non-signatory, we have every rights to say NO to them.

Nonetheless, the government should also inspect the living atmosphere of the refugees in the country. As long as they are here, it is our responsibility to ensure their welfare is being taken care off. Otherwise, the whole world will never stop pointing fingers (esp their middle fingers) towards us.

Please investigate the allegations that the refugees are living in a very poor condition, with not enough food to eat, no clean water.... and that some of them had to become thieves to survive. This is humiliating.

So, if we really want to help them, give them some assurance that they will get proper treatments to suffice their living here until another country agrees to accept them.

Our PM and the respective ministers rarely spoke about the refugees. I don't think members of the Press have visited the refugee camps, one of which is near the KLIA. Or they didnt find issues pertaining to refugees a burning point to write of...

We cannot depend much on the UNHCR. They are only tasked to find faults in countries like us, rag our goodwill and tarnish our image. We can always question how many times in a year that their officials visited the refugees camps.

And if we don't care about them, leave them to rot!

layari link di bawah untuk membaca artikel penuh
http://justread-whatever.blogspot.com/2011/09/malaysia-is-too-dangerous.html

@HishammuddinH2O - Sending asylum seekers to Nauru won't stop human traffickers

Nauru not the solution: Malaysia

Tom Allard, Kuala Lumpur

September 16, 2011

http://www.theage.com.au/national/nauru-not-the-solution-malaysia-20110915-1kby9.html

Malaysian minister Hishammuddin Hussein. Photo: Rahman Roslan

THE Coalition's proposal to send asylum seekers to Nauru is highly unlikely to stop human traffickers sending boats to Australia, according to Malaysia's Home Affairs Minister, Hishammuddin Hussein.

In an interview with The Age, Mr Hishammuddin said Malaysia remained strongly committed to the refugee exchange with Australia.

He also vowed that any asylum seekers Australia sent to Malaysia under the plan would not be abused and that Malaysia was working to improve the treatment of refugees and illegal workers in the country.

Mr Hishammuddin's comments are the first by the Malaysian government since the High Court rejected the proposed deal under which Australia would accepted 4000 genuine refugees from Malaysia and transferred the 800 people who arrived in Australia by boat. It comes as the Gillard government prepares legislation to amend the Migration Act to overcome the ruling and pave the way for offshore processing in the hope of stopping asylum seekers taking boats.

The opposition has yet to decide whether it will support the bill, but Mr Hishammuddin said its plan to send asylum seekers to Nauru was flawed because the remote Pacific island was not a transit country for asylum seekers like Malaysia and, as such, it would not deter people smugglers. ''Can you help me that the Nauru solution is the right solution? That people won't see Malaysia as a transit point on the way to the Nauru solution, and then on to Australia and New Zealand?'' he said.

The opposition and refugee advocates have slammed Malaysia's human rights record because Malaysia is not a signatory to the United Nations convention on refugees and has detained illegal immigrants and, in some cases, caned them.

However, an understanding with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees for the past two years means refugees in Malaysia should live free from detention and caning. Malaysia has taken steps in recent years to address such concerns and overnight its Prime Minister, Najib Razak, is expected to flag the dismantling of its 40-year-old Internal Security Act that allows indefinite detention without trial.

Meanwhile, in Australia yesterday, Greens leader Bob Brown came face to face with the bureaucratic ''turkeys'' he condemned last week, to discuss claims made after a confidential media briefing about asylum seekers.

Senator Brown met Andrew Metcalfe, who confirmed that at the briefing, the issue of asylum seekers arriving in Europe had come up. But Mr Metcalfe denied he had linked this to riots.

And in a letter to The Age, the legal team that sank the Malaysian ''people-swap'' plan has defended the man who advised the Gillard government on the court challenge.

With MICHELLE GRATTAN, MICHAEL GORDON

Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/national/nauru-not-the-solution-malaysia-20110915-1kby9.html#ixzz1YFPPcZ00

@HishammuddinH2O - Are you telling Malaysia is worse than the human traffickers?

Don't give up on deal: Malaysia

Tom Allard in Kuala Lumpur and Phillip Coorey

September 16, 2011

http://www.smh.com.au/national/dont-give-up-on-deal-malaysia-20110915-1kbzv.html

"If Malaysia doesn't do something, we will always be seen

as a transit country" ... Hishammuddin Hussein.

Photo: Rahman Roslan

MALAYSIA remains strongly committed to the refugee exchange with Australia, with its Home Affairs Minister criticising the Coalition's alternative of sending asylum seekers to Nauru as highly unlikely to stop human traffickers.

In an exclusive interview with the Herald, Hishammuddin Hussein also vowed that any asylum seekers Australia sent to Malaysia under the plan would not be abused and that Malaysia was working to improve the treatment of refugees and illegal workers in the country.

His comments are the first by the Malaysian government since the High Court rejected the deal under which Australia would send Malaysia 800 asylum seekers in return for accepting 4000 refugees.

They come as the Gillard government appeals to the Coalition to support changes to the Migration Act to overcome the court ruling and allow it to send asylum seekers offshore.

The Herald has also learnt that the Opposition Leader, Tony Abbott, who will be briefed on the Migration Act changes this afternoon, is likely to demand the government support the reintroduction of temporary protection visas in return for his support.

Labor would be unable to accede, giving the Coalition an excuse to walk away from the deal, which it believes is not needed anyway, and revive its preferred Pacific solution policy.

The visas, which Labor judged cruel and inefficient, were abolished in 2008 and Ms Gillard told Parliament yesterday it was not government policy to reintroduce them.

The government needs Coalition support for the legislation, which would give Australia the discretion to send asylum seekers wherever it wished.

Labor wants to use a swift return to Malaysia as a deterrent to break people-smuggling, and Manus Island as a back-up processing centre. The opposition wants to revive the Pacific solution of processing asylum seekers in Nauru and Manus Island.

Immigration Department officials have warned the Pacific solution would not work again as a deterrent because asylum seekers now knew they would end up in Australia or New Zealand.

Mr Hishammuddin concurred. Nauru was not a transit country for asylum seekers like Malaysia and, as such, it would not deter people smugglers.

''Can you help me that the Nauru solution is the right solution? That people won't see Malaysia as a transit point on the way to the Nauru solution, and then on to Australia and New Zealand?'' he said. ''If Malaysia doesn't do something, we will always be seen as a transit country.''

In his strongest language yet, Mr Abbott said he was unlikely to help the government unless the changes to the Migration Act allowed the Pacific solution and temporary protection visas but not Malaysia.

''If she [Ms Gillard] wants us to support her policy she needs to take the appropriate steps. She'd better get her policy to resemble what we think is in the national interest,'' he said.

The opposition and refugee advocates have slammed Malaysia's human rights record because it is not a signatory to the United Nations refugee convention, has detained illegal immigrants and, in some cases, has caned them.

However, an understanding with the UN High Commissioner for Refugees for the past two years means refugees in Malaysia should live free from detention and caning.

''Are you are telling me Malaysia is so bad that we are worse than the human traffickers?'' asked Mr Hishammuddin.

''There will be a mechanism when we operationalise this. In the world these days, you cannot hide things any more. Any abuse would be displayed for the world to see instantaneously. We will have to be very careful, if we are allowed to carry on, to ensure that everything is done properly.''

Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/national/dont-give-up-on-deal-malaysia-20110915-1kbzv.html#ixzz1YFNTDiur

Info Pemerdagangan Manusia - ia boleh berlaku ke atas mereka dan anda atau keluarga anda juga. Elak sebelum kena!

Pemerdagangan manusia merupakan suatu kegiatan yang sangat zalim dan tidak berperikemanusian. Sindiket memperdagangkan manusia menjanjikan kehidupan yang baik di negara ini, malangnya apabila mangsa sampai ke sini, mereka telah diperdagangkan ibarat barang. Wanita dilacurkan. Anak-anak dijadikan peminta sedekah. Ia bukan sahaja melibatkan mangsa yang ingin bekerja di sini, tetapi termasuklah pelarian dari negara yang kacau bilau dan mereka yang diperdagangkan secara paksa. Ia boleh berlaku kepada mereka yang ingin datang ke Malaysia, ia juga boleh berlaku ke atas anda dan keluarga anda!

Info MyMassa : Banteras Pemerdagangan Orang dan Penyeludupan Migran

3:32 PM MymassaVoice

Klik untuk besarkan imej.